The Right's Hypocrisy is Not Their Weakness - It's Their Strength
Charlie Kirk is in the news again, yay! Not because he suddenly returned from vacation and was baffled that everyone was under the impression he was dead, but for a much more boring reason: Dave Chapelle was recently recorded on a potato phone at a live comedy event making a joke about Kirk’s death with the punchline clipped out.
So first of all, obviously there’s a lot more to this bit and whoever decided to just truncate out the entire joke part of whatever joke Chapelle was making here was acting with deliberate intent. And I’m not even arguing that the punchline was hilarious or even landed at all, because I don’t know what the punchline even was, and neither, apparently, does anybody. At least, none of the audience, as of me posting this, has given any further context.
It doesn’t matter what the rest of the joke was, anyway, because the problem is the fact that a joke was made and the right are trying to rekindle the cancellation marathon they threw last year immediately after he was killed, when online vigilantes set up surveillance parties to scour social media for anyone displaying insufficient grief about his death. These mofos worked in shifts for like a month, aggressively doxing and mass-reporting to their employers anyone who was found to have made an uncharitable comment about Kirk online, whether it was an outright celebration or someone merely pointing out the irony of his death relative to his stated philosophical position on gun violence (specifically, that the current rate of unjustified gun deaths in America is an acceptable sacrifice for a robust interpretation of the Second Amendment.)
That is a perfectly reasonable point to bring up! And, in an attempt to shield myself from any such retribution, I wish to God that murder hadn’t happened. But it did, and nobody can change what happened, and it’s therefore pretty damn open-for-discussion the question of whether Kirk, and those who agree with him on the subject of gun violence, are willing to extend the “worth it” umbrella to the murder of Kirk himself. Or, alternatively, are you “literally doing the meme” about the villain from Shrek? You know the one I mean.

It would be hypocritical to specifically exclude certain individuals from the “worth it” category who weren’t specified in the original statement, right? It’s completely valid to question whether Kirk and those who shared his beliefs on this topic were actually extending the definition of “worthwhile” gun violence to public figures, or whether they’re kind of just throwing acceptable economic and racial underclasses under the bus here. It’s a question made more pertinent by the fact that Kirk’s literal final words in the mortal realm were to dismiss most gun violence as a “gang” thing.
The doxing campaign that followed Kirk’s murder took place at a time that kind of feels alien, now, even though it was just a year ago—in mid-to-late 2025, Trump’s MAGA coalition felt like it was still consolidating power to a terrifying degree and every institution was falling in lockstep with its ideological mission. In the days after Kirk was shot, a lot of people thought that Trump was going to do something drastic like declare martial law or some shit, and a lot of institutions were extremely eager to comply for their own survival. These people put so many heads on pikes. A huge number of people got fired from their jobs just for quoting Kirk’s own words in a way that made a point about his beliefs.

I noticed at the time that a number of these doxing campaigns were using the online tipping service Buy Me a Coffee to finance themselves. This is the company that I, myself, use to solicit one-off donation payments for my newsletter. I found that some of the people running these campaigns were explicitly and openly targeting racial and sexual minorities, which is very much against BMAC’s terms of service, so I submitted a complaint with ample evidence. They nevertheless declined to intervene with these fundraisers even where the people running them were quoting Hitler.
I don’t recount this to shame BMAC in particular, and hell, I’m still using their service. Find me any company that would have stood up against even Hitler-quoters at the height of their wrath in support of an assassination victim that the Vice President was claiming as one of his best friends. My point is that this was an event that made it explicitly obvious that corporations and institutions will never step up and save us from fascism should it arrive, and I know a lot of you will say “duh” to that, but you may not understand exactly why.

Here's what paid subscribers are reading right now:

It’s not because the heads of these companies are all secretly turbofascists. They’re largely as milquetoast liberal as the general population. That’s actually their weakness, and my larger point: It’s not so much that they don’t want to appear liberal, it’s that they don’t want to appear hypocritical.
Organizations with liberal values will concede to complaints made by a far-right mob if they think it will make them seem unbiased, and thus, retain the moral high ground. If some community college or bank or Arby’s had fired someone for going online and making a bunch of George Floyd jokes, then they wouldn’t want to appear hypocritical by turning a blind eye to Charlie Kirk jokes. You might balk at the idea that these organizations have consistent principles, but even the ones that don’t would find it compelling to try to “reach across the aisle” at a time when the MAGA faithful were acting in ways that seemed genuinely frightening.

But those of us who were paying attention knew that what they were doing was less extending an olive branch and more like banal capitulation.
Now, there has been no shortage of people pointing out that these campaigns from the right are incredibly hypocritical if you take their notions of liberation from cancel culture seriously. They can bleat on about how they just want to hold everyone to consistent principles, but if they had any consistency in their own principles then they wouldn’t want anyone getting fired for a Charlie kirk joke or anybody. People focus on the hypocrisy to try to win a rhetorical argument, but it doesn’t work—they don’t care and it doesn’t hurt them.
Think of it this way: The charge of hypocrisy is an attack on one’s principles. The MAGA right knows that principles are a weakness, which is why they don’t have any. If the battle between MAGA and everyone else was one of competing principles then it would put their culture war at a stalemate at best, but more likely on the back foot.
What appear to be principles on the far right are whims of preference. There’s an irony to the fact that they are so closely associated with the Christian faith because what they embody is a full rejection of the Christian mode of moral reasoning, what Nietzsche called the slave morality, in favor of perpetual power politics and might-makes-right. Indeed, prominent Catholics have recently denounced and left their faith over issues that Donald Trump has with it, and everyone knows that Donald Trump is an atheist. Miss me with any half-assed arguments otherwise.

To put it another way, the things on the far right that appear to be principles are really just “stuff we don’t want to see or that grosses us out or annoys us.” That isn’t a principle, in reality, because it shifts and is so malleable that they could never hold themselves to account for it. But to present it that way would just make them sound like a bunch of children, so they articulate it in ways that sound broadly like principles, but aren’t.
That’s how you get, for example, Lauren Boebert standing up for Christian family values “in principle” but then giving a guy a handjob in a public theater. People can and did call Boebert a hypocrite for this, but I question whether the charge of hypocrisy even applies to these people. After all, the presence of principles feels like it’s actually requisite to being a hypocrite at all. In Boebert’s case, it feels actually quite consistent. What’s coded as “family values” is that Boebert doesn’t want to see a bunch of gay or transgender people walking around, but wants to preserve her own right to do some hetero sex stuff in public if she feels like it. There’s no real conflict between Stuff She Wants and Other Stuff She Wants.

One of the biggest misconceptions that has somehow squeezed through into the zeitgeist is that the right are the big “free speech” guys. In reality it’s very difficult to find anyone who’s passionate about freedom of speech and very consistent about it across all of the political landscape. Most people have a preference that people they agree with be allowed to say the stuff they agree with, and the people they disagree with either shut up and go away or get reprimanded. I like to think of myself as a robust free speech guy, but I don’t think many people strongly hold that as a principle, or even think about it that much, anywhere on the political spectrum.
Dave Chapelle has been promoted for years by the right as one of their favorite comedians, specifically because he does this exact kind of transgressive comedy without giving any thought to who it might offend. That’s great when he’s making jokes about liberal snowflakes and transgender people, but suddenly unacceptable when he’s talking about Charlie Kirk.
This isn’t because he suddenly violated a principle. Again, the far right don’t have principles. What they do have in place of principles is strategies. I don’t like some of what Dave Chappelle appears to believe but I’m fine with him being able to say it. He seems pretty consistent in his principles. Someone like Chappelle easily loses the support of the right, not because he violated some principle, but because he lost his utility.
The right has established strategies for winning public support that have nothing to do with principles. You’ll see terms like “never punch right,” which means that there should be no public disagreements visible between any two people on the political right, no matter how far apart their specific preferences may be, because they’ll never have as much disagreement with each other as either of them have with the left-of-center. Or, the “no bad tactics, only bad targets” strategy that became gospel way back during Gamergate, when they questioned whether any action, up to and including “swatting,” may be off the table in the culture war.
Sometimes the right will publicly acknowledge all this, and it’s always a little surprising to me when they do, even though it shouldn’t be—they live on the same open web as the rest of us, and discuss their methods on the same open media, but still it feels a bit surprising when the conspiracy, such as it is, is laid out on Twitter instead of some smoke-filled room, or at least some private group chat.

I’ve talked before about how MAGA media strategist Christopher Rufo is fully open about how much he lies online, what his specific strategies for doing so are, and how much the mainstream media doesn’t care for some reason and still cites him as some kind of expert. The best analysis I’ve heard from the horse’s mouth (and he does look like a horse) about this specific strategy comes from the far right Twitch streamer Asmongold, speaking about how there is no even theoretical tactic so immoral that it’s off the table.
So: About this latest round of cancellations over Charlie Kirk jokes? Yeah, it’s not going so well.
With respect to Charlie Kirk’s family—and I do earnestly feel bad for them—the United States midterm elections kind of BTFO’d this second round of cancellations that MAGA had hoped for. Even for months beforehand, all of the cancellations initially ordered by the Trump mob have been falling apart: There’s a Twitter account that follows all of the successful court settlements that have been awarded to people who were fired for saying something about Charlie Kirk that, it turns out, was protected speech all along.

I'm writing a book about right-wing reactionary movements in tech and geek culture in general. The working title is How Geeks Ate the World and if you like this newsletter then you'll probably like my book. I've been dropping parts of the draft as the project comes along—but only for paid subscribers.

Here's what paid subscribers are reading right now:

